Greenpan vs Caraway : Which One Should You Buy?
GreenPan is a Belgian brand and one of the pioneers in the ceramic non-stick cookware movement. Caraway is a new, fresh-faced startup offering ceramic non-stick cookware that’s colorful, fun, and uniquely designed. So, which ceramic non-stick cookware is better?
In this GreenPan vs. Caraway comparison, you’ll learn how their cookware differs in terms of construction, design, durability, performance, price, and more.
Greenpan vs. Caraway: What’s the difference?
Caraway Offers Better Transparency, Giving You Greater Peace of Mind
Caraway Home is very responsive and largely transparent when we’ve asked about third-party testing of its cookware. The company has given us a whole slew of test reports and all show the cookware passes with flying colors: No PFAS, and no heavy metal leaching, as well as no heavy metals in the actual coating.
In contrast, GreenPan stopped providing any test results publicly in 2020 and is very secretive about its non-stick coating. Though the company still markets itself as non-toxic and free from heavy metals and PFAS.
The primary reason to choose ceramic nonstick cookware is its enhanced safety compared to traditional nonstick products. While GreenPan’s lack of transparency doesn’t necessarily indicate issues with their quality, brands that prioritize openness tend to build stronger trust with users. If absolute peace of mind is your top priority, Caraway stands out as the more reliable choice.
No matter which brand you select, gentle care is key to maintaining ceramic-coated pans. Avoid scratches by using soft utensils and proper cleaning methods—this simple diligence ensures long-lasting performance and safety.
GreenPan Performs Better on Induction Stoves
Not all GreenPan cookware works with induction, but their induction-compatible lines feature a patented copper-reinforced base for excellent performance.
Caraway Home cookware is fully induction-compatible, though some stovetops may not detect it properly. For best results, your cooktop should have 6-inch and 8-inch burners to fit their pans.
If induction cooking is a priority, GreenPan’s specialized design may be the better choice.
Both GreenPan and Caraway are oven-safe.
All Caraway Home cookware is oven-safe up to 550°F.
GreenPan’s newer collections withstand up to 600°F, but its original Rio line is only safe to 350°F. Some GreenPan pieces also have non-oven-safe handles (like wood), so always check product details before stovetop-to-oven use.
GreenPan Has Superior Durability
GreenPan claims its Infinite8 and Thermolon Advanced coatings are scratch-resistant, durable, and even safe for metal utensils and dishwashers. While no ceramic coating lasts forever—some may just extend the lifespan by months—GreenPan’s tougher finish makes it a better choice for busy kitchens or less careful cooks.
Caraway’s ceramic coating, however, is more delicate—avoid metal utensils and dishwashers. Plus, once the coating wears down, its aluminum core may leach into food, unlike GreenPan’s 3-ply and 5-ply stainless steel options. If you need affordable, low-maintenance cookware, GreenPan is the smarter pick.
GreenPan vs. Caraway: Which Should You Choose?
Picking between GreenPan and Caraway depends on your priorities.
- GreenPan offers more affordable, durable options—some even dishwasher and metal-utensil safe. Their 3-ply and 5-ply stainless steel lines work well on induction and avoid aluminum exposure.
- Caraway is more transparent about testing and sustainability but requires gentler care (no metal utensils or dishwashers). Once its coating wears, aluminum exposure becomes a concern.
Both brands are PTFE- and PFAS-free. If transparency matters most, Caraway wins for now—but if GreenPan shares more third-party test results, that could change.
Bottom line: Need durability and value? Go GreenPan. Prefer eco-conscious branding? Caraway.
Greenpan vs Caraway: Comparison Chart
| GreenPan | Caraway | |
| Founded | 2007 | 2018 |
| Where It’s Made | China | China and India |
| Base Material | Aluminum, hard-anodized, or fully-clad 3-ply stainless steel | Heavy-gauge aluminum with a steel induction plate |
| Free from | Results not available (brand says free of PFAS, PFOA, lead and cadmium) | PFOA, PTFE, other PFAS, hard anodization (and potentially toxic manufacturing byproducts) |
| Leach testing results | Results not available (brand says free of heavy metals) | No lead, cadmium, titanium, or other heavy metal leaching |
| Cooking Surface | Diamond-infused ceramic non-stick | Ceramic non-stick |
| Oven-Safe | Between 350°F and 600°F, depending on the collection | 500°F |
| Dishwasher-Safe | Yes (except the Lima collection) | No |
| Induction-Compatible | Yes | Yes |
| Warranty | 2 yrs for ceramic coating, lifetime for rest of product | 1-year warranty for major damage to the body, handles, lids or functional impairment |
| Top Reasons to Buy | Natural non-stick materials, variety of styles and colors, excellent heat conduction, affordable | Natural non-stick materials, modern and colorful design, simple shopping experience (one collection) |
| Top Reasons to NOT Buy | Less durable than traditional non-stick, low oven-safe temperatures (certain collections) | Less durable than traditional non-stick, more expensive than most GreenPan collections, exterior coating is prone to chipping |
| Buy on Amazon | Check Price on Amazon | Check Price on Amazon |
